Fifth Avenue Forum

Dave Keon vs Uncle Daddy

Just career impact wise...Dineen still beats out Jack...but it won't be for too, too much longer. Either way, you're going on empty...or Wardo if you go to '06...you're going to live.

Dave Keon vs Uncle Daddy

All due respect to the great Davey Keon...but you're f'd, son...

Yeah, my choices pretty much sealed my fate. I could have gone with Mike Smith and his 1 career goal. Goalie v Goalie

get Beveridge a body bag

Patrick Dwyer or Paul Stanton against Nikolai Khabibulin.

I hope someone carries on my legacy of Pitt and Pirates angst.

I'm not sure I could be more dead.

Ron Greschner or Kirk Maltby on Patrick Roy.

Okay. This is as satisfying as opening those free HUT packs you get when you buy an EA NHL game.

The rest of my list:
I get Steve Kariya. Paul nowhere to be found.

Just career impact wise...Dineen still beats out Jack...but it won't be for too, too much longer. Either way, you're going on empty...or Wardo if you go to '06...you're going to live.

For sure, but would ever take Dineen over Eichel in a PS sitz? Hell nah.

Patrick Dwyer or Paul Stanton against Nikolai Khabibulin.

I hope someone carries on my legacy of Pitt and Pirates angst.

I thought you were 50...

I just look bad for my age.

Connor McDavid on Chris Osgood

Kane is safer than mikey and I

Yeah, I figured Kovy on an empty net was a lock...but he could conceivably not try that shift and just throw a no-look saucer to nowhere...Kane's definitely gonna live...

I'm not sure I could be more dead.

Ron Greschner or Kirk Maltby on Patrick Roy.

Okay. This is as satisfying as opening those free HUT packs you get when you buy an EA NHL game.

The rest of my list:

Ian Turnbull
Paul Fenton
Stefan Persson
Norm Gratton
Walt Atanas
Bob Fitchner
Stan Neckar
Steve Kariya
Travis Dermott
Sandy Fitzpatrick
Babe Donnelly
Peter Fiorentino

I get Steve Kariya. Paul nowhere to be found.

Actually, I think your best bet (and best career value) is Stefan Persson. Turnbull had a bomb, IIRC too...

But, going against Roy...yeah, you're f'd, son...

Patrick Dwyer was 1 for 1 on penalty shots in his career. I might live after all.

Yikes: Alexei Yashin vs. Ken Dryden

Y'all, I think I'm a goner.

Dryden was brutal against Russians...

2-2 | 4.75 GAA | .838 save pct. in '72 Canada Cup
Tied 3-3 against the Red Army during Super Series '76.
1-1 | 3.50 GAA | .863 save pct. in the 1979 Challenge Cup

You also have Zherdev and Berezin if you go to a whole shootout...you got a real shot at this...not from a career value point of view (Dryden wins easily...) but in this small snapshot...

Captain Intangibles vs Jean-Sébastien Giguère

Syd Howe or Brian Rafalski vs. Martin Brodeur

I’m screwed

Mark Scheifele vs. Ed Belfour. Peace out.

hmmm......Jake DeBrusk shooting on Grant Fuhr. does it have to be an NHL player? because Natalie Spooner from Team Canada is a pretty darned good player.....

One of my friends is 12/21 (best player is Joey Kocur), I thought that was gonna be the worst...but your best career value is Ken Morrow...that's down there, not Kocur bad, but it's down there...

Jordan Eberle vs Nikolai Khabiboulin

That would be interesting...

Tony Granato vs Mike Vernon?

I kinda feel like I have a shot but... Tony G doe....

Harry Watson vs Ray Emery

meh