Is a hot dog a sandwich? **poll reset, please vote again**

[the wicked child]

This is hands down the best post in this thread.

[dodint]

Putting hot dog at true neutral instead of radical anarchy invalidates it.

wtf chip butty?

[count2infinity]

We have a ton of radical hard line purists on this board. Being able to comprehend that a hot dog is a sandwich is pretty neutral. A poptart is radical, not a hot dog.

[NailedPenguin]

This is hands down the best post in this thread.

If everything is a sandwich then nothing is a sandwich.

[dodint]

Source of the post We have a ton of radical hard line purists on this board.

Because it's normal and one of the more easily recognizable cultural mores. Shouting your claim or making a silly chart doesn't invalidate it. You can't pray the sandwich away.

And I thought you were a scientist.

[count2infinity]

[columbia]

I would say that an ice cream sandwich is indeed a sandwich.

[MrKennethTKangaroo]

really could go for one of those ice cream tacos now

[Silentom]

Choco Taco's are legit.

[mikey]

Putting hot dog at true neutral instead of radical anarchy invalidates it.

wtf chip butty?

Yeah, that chart had a lot of upside until the hot dog was considered some sort of middle ground...if it was "radical of center" I'd be more inclined to buy it...

I have no idea what a "chip butty" is...likely because my BMI doesn't match my age...

[tifosi77]

Perfection

[dodint]

More proof that chart is WRONG.

[Beveridge]

I'm a structure purist, ingredient rebel all the way.

[Troy Loney]

I am to the left of 'true neutral"

I assume no one thinks a choco taco is a sandwich...right?

[slappybrown]

I think MIMH is the only hardline traditionalist IIRC based on discussions of requiring separation of the bread.

[Troy Loney]

So a chip butty is clearly a sandwich, but it's also stupid and British and in no way helps the discussion.

[OutofFoil]

What about this monstrosity?

[llipgh2]

I've never had a choco taco.

[columbia]

I've never had a choco taco.

You should remedy that.

[llipgh2]

Perhaps. LOL

[shafnutz05]

Joey Chestnut, hot dog eating champion, at the All-Star Fanfest yesterday:

“You start considering a hot dog a sandwich, and you’re like ‘oh, because there’s carbs around it,’ then you have to start, kinda, is a gyro a sandwich? ‘Cause that’s kinda like ... no. You have to keep division.”

A firm no to the OP's question, from the world's leading authority on hot dogs. Case closed.

[columbia]

That's like saying that Homer Simpson is an authority on beer. No, he just drinks a lot of it.

[meow]

Homer Simpson is a cartoon

[mikey]

Valid point.

[count2infinity]

I'm sure the world's best chess players, racecar drivers, and poker players consider their activity a sport... doesn't mean they're correct. You're better than this, shad.